Hundreds of cases dropped over evidence disclosure failings

30th January 2018

Hundreds of cases dropped over evidence disclosure failings

The right to a fair trial is one of the fundamental principles of a just society, protecting anyone facing criminal or civil charges with a number of enshrined guarantees.

These include the assurance that the hearing will be held in public, by an independent and impartial court or tribunal, and within a reasonable time. A fair trial also affords the defendant full access to the documents and evidence in the case, regardless of whether or not that undermines the prosecution’s position.

However, data uncovered by the BBC suggests that police and prosecutors are increasingly failing to meet the requirement of disclosure, resulting in rising numbers of collapsed cases – at a huge cost to the public purse and to the emotional wellbeing of those wrongly charged.

The number of prosecutions in England and Wales that were thrown out over the last two years has leapt by 70% – up from 537 in 2014/15 to 916 in 2016/17.

In December, the trial of Liam Allan, who faced 12 counts of rape and sexual assault, collapsed when it emerged evidence on a computer disc – which police had looked through – showed messages from the alleged victim pestering him for “casual sex”.

And earlier this month, a rape charge against Oxford University student Oliver Mears was dropped on the eve of his trial after a diary that supported his case was uncovered.

The human cost to both men will have been immense and made worse by suffering the stigma of being named as alleged rapists with their names wrongly attached to a heinous crime.

Worse still is the serious potential for – and the likelihood of – miscarriage of justice. Jerry Hayes, the prosecuting barrister in Liam Allan’s case, fears innocent people are “probably” being jailed because of disclosure failings: “It may have been some time ago and it may well be that evidence is destroyed. Their lives are now destroyed.”

Criminal barristers say the problem of non-disclosure of relevant material is widespread and not restricted to sex offence cases.

Robin Murray, the former vice chair of the Criminal Law Solicitors Association, said 99 percent of lawyers the group surveyed last year had encountered disclosure failures, which, he added, “showed there are systemic evidential disclosure failures across all different crimes”.

So what’s causing the problem?

Shadow Attorney General Shami Chakrabarti points the finger at austerity in the justice system, adding that the increasing prevalence of social media and text messaging has made the handing over of evidence to lawyers an increasingly labour-intensive process.

Angela Rafferty QC, chair of the Criminal Bar Association, echoed those sentiments, blaming the problem on a “lack of investment, training and attention to the criminal justice system”. She said barristers face “a daily struggle in respect of disclosure, delays and all the other disastrous consequences of a system that is openly described by MPs as at breaking point”.

Meanwhile, a report issued in July by HM CPS Inspectorate and HM Inspectorate of Constabulary found that officers were “often ignorant” of their disclosure responsibilities. “Non-compliance with the disclosure process is not new and has been common knowledge amongst those engaged within the criminal justice system for many years,” the damning report concluded.

It all raises troubling questions about the fairness of the justice system and its ability to cope with evidence in a rapidly changing world.

For too long, disclosure has been seen by police and prosecutors as an administrative inconvenience rather than an integral element of the process. That must change, no matter how difficult the task, if we are to protect the basic principles of justice at the heart of a fair society.

Practice Areas
Criminal Law Solicitors
Blog Posts

Family Mediation Week: Why family mediation can make the task of separation a little easier


When a relationship breaks down and a family splits, there may be feelings of…

Read More
Upcoming Events

Inheritance Tax and Wills Planning Seminar


What the seminar will cover... Inheritance Tax: - When does it apply; what are…

Read More
News Posts

Employers must provide itemised payslips from April 2019


Employers will have to itemise payslips for employees’ wages which vary depending on how…

Read More


"The friendliness of Sally Pryke making me feel at ease during the whole process"

- BV

"Always kept me informed of the progress"

- CP

"Helen Stuart was fantastic and I couldn't have asked for a better solicitor!"

- KM

"Everything was dealt with in a compassionate and friendly manner"

- AW

"Pat's service is always extremely efficient and very approachable"

- AO

"Relieved that I could leave you to deal with the legal aspect of my late husbands estate"

- DG

"We cannot thank you enough for all your hard work and sticking with us. You have been amazing and showed a lot of patience when dealing with this case and all for no reward for yourself, thank you."

- Dean Kentfield

"Approachable, very efficient, always willing to take my calls and update me."

- SH

"We were very pleased to have Jade as our solicitor, the service was excellent and we felt kept in the loop which minimised stress"

- CT

"I have used Tracey Hammond at Gotelee on a number of occasions and in my opinion, she is simply the most efficient conveyancing solicitor I have ever worked with. From the outset, she took the time to understand my specific business requirements and to date, she has exceeded all of my expectations."

- Dale Fiddy - Portobello Developments Ltd

Please select preferred method of contact

* We will only contact you by telephone if you select this as primary form of contact.