Asbestos Claim highlights the importance of evidence

10th June 2014

Asbestos Claim highlights the importance of evidence

In a case which bitterly revealed the difficulty faced by litigants involved in historic asbestos cases, a widow who claimed that her husband’s death was caused by exposure to the lethal substance whilst working in a cemetery in the 1970s has received a judge’s sympathy – but not a penny in compensation.

The widow’s bricklayer husband of 40 years had – four months before he died from cancer in 2011 – recounted details of how he had inhaled asbestos dust whilst decorating a ceiling in a graveyard building. Her lawyers claimed that his employer at the time, a local authority, had failed in the duty of care it owed him.

The Court found that the widow was a ‘witness of truth’ and that her husband had probably been describing work that he had done on the ceiling of a mess room used by gravediggers. However, three subsequent surveys of the building had not revealed any traces of asbestos.

The judge ruled, “At the end of the day, I am driven to the conclusion that, whatever he must have believed on looking back at events, I am not satisfied that there was any form of plaster or decorative coating that contained asbestos. Whilst I have great sympathy with the deceased, and for his widow, I am compelled to conclude that the burden of proof has not been discharged and that the claim must be dismissed.”

This unfortunate case highlights the vital importance of ensuring that a full and detailed account is obtained from the person suffering from the asbestos related disease as to where, how and when he worked with asbestos before it is too late and the evidence is lost.

Instructing a solicitor following diagnosis will help to ensure that as much evidence as possible can be obtained at an early stage, including details of other workers who may have worked with the asbestos victim since there evidence can often be crucial to help support a compensation claim.

If you, or someone you know needs legal assistance in respect of any related issues please contact James Davies on0800 091 4251 or complete our online enquiry form.

Blog Posts

Is your fulfilment business under threat?


The Fulfilment House Due Diligence Scheme - the new weapon in the war on…

Read More
Upcoming Events

FREE Seminar – Planning your future


Gotelee Solicitors invite you to a FREE seminar which will provide you with some…

Read More
News Posts

Ruling means employers may soon have to deal with problems they thought were closed


The Supreme Court’s decision to rule that Employment Tribunal fees are ‘illegal’ and a…

Read More


"Friendly and helpful staff. A smooth and efficient legal service."

- MR

"Professional yet friendly service available from a conveniently located office."

- JR

"Clear, helpful advice, polite and friendly, prompt attention."

- GP

"High degree of professionalism whilst remaining sympathetic and friendly."

- PC

"Helpful and swift service, delivered in a friendly and approachable way."

- AC

"Gotelee inspires a sense of calm, confidence, trust & history."

- PB

"Determination, patience and diligence of Chris Moffat."


"Diana really seemed to care and made the whole process as painless as possible."

- PL

"Rhonda Pryke was very helpful, explained what was to happen, dealt with queries very efficiently."

- DH

"All reception staff very friendly, Hilary Durrell made everything simple so I could understand what was needed."

- AD

Please select preferred method of contact

* We will only contact you by telephone if you select this as primary form of contact.