Banoffee Pies Incident Led to Fair Dismissal

3rd June 2014

Banoffee Pies Incident Led to Fair Dismissal

A warehouse manager who was sacked for disobeying an instruction to load four banoffee pies onto a lorry before he went home at the end of his shift has been stripped of his right to compensation by the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT).

The man had worked as manager of the foodstuffs warehouse for seven years and had suffered from work-related stress in the past. His employer was of the view that his performance was declining and he had been given warnings in relation to his dealings with more junior staff and his failure to do as he was told. The pies incident triggered disciplinary proceedings that led to his dismissal for misconduct.

The Employment Tribunal (ET) upheld his claim for unfair dismissal and awarded him substantial damages on the basis that the pies incident, which had happened when he was exhausted at the end of a 13-hour shift, was ‘so slight a matter’ that dismissal fell outside the range of reasonable responses that was open to the employer.

In upholding the employer’s appeal and ruling that the man’s dismissal was fair, the EAT found that the ET had fallen into the trap of substituting its own view as to the seriousness of the matter for that of the employer. A thorough disciplinary procedure had been followed; the employer genuinely believed that it was a case of misconduct and, in failing to load the pies when instructed to do so, the man had been guilty of ‘flat disobedience’.

Comment

This case emphasises that it is the role of the ET to decide if dismissal fell within the range of reasonable responses for an employer to take, and it is not for them to determine what they would have done in that scenario. Although at one end of the scale one employer might not have dismissed in these circumstances, it was nevertheless reasonable for this employer to have done so given the fact that the employer was satisfied that this was a case of disobedience, rather than forgetfulness, and the employee had already been given previous warnings for not doing as he was told.

Blog Posts

Heart Attacks and why women are more at risk

06/12/2019

A British Heart Foundation report released this year found that women who suffer heart…

Read More
Upcoming Events

How to ensure your employees really ARE your greatest asset

24/09/2019

This is an invitation only event. Gotelee's employment law Partners, Andrew West and Marie…

Read More
News Posts

Gotelee Solicitors LLP welcomes new Dispute Resolution Partner to commercial team

05/11/2019

The Partners and staff are delighted to welcome Andrew Breckenridge to the firm from…

Read More

Testimonials

"I would like to say thank you for your help, support and guidance over the last two and a half years. Obviously should I need further assistance in the future I shall not hesitate to call you guys."

-

"Approachable, very efficient, always willing to take my calls and update me."

- SH

"I have used Tracey Laflin at Gotelee on a number of occasions and in my opinion, she is simply the most efficient conveyancing solicitor I have ever worked with. From the outset, she took the time to understand my specific business requirements and to date, she has exceeded all of my expectations."

- Dale Fiddy - Portobello Developments Ltd

"Jade Shelton was absolutely fantastic!! Professional and proactive at all times."

- JH

"The ease that we could access and speak to Pat Smith - Thank you"

-

"We found Rachel Dawson outstanding, polite, professional and caring."

-

"Prompt, helpful, polite and very professional service"

-

"“ This is the second time we have used Tracey for the conveyancing to buy our new home. She is always completely approachable, she has helped us along the way with advice and useful tips that has helped lessen the stress. We have complete confidence in her and would not hesitate to recommend her to our friends and family”.  - Peter Dawes, Cater Dawes Financial Planning "

-

"I don't think this house sale would have pulled together without Jo's determination and expertise. Excellent!"

- MT

"This is by far the go-to firm for any issues. You are made to feel valued from the outset and they are so confident in what they do. Wouldn't recommend any other. Thank you Hugh and Max."

- Ros Jones

Please select preferred method of contact

* We will only contact you by telephone if you select this as primary form of contact. All web enquiries will be stored on our website for 30 days.