Proportionality rule makes mockery of justice, says rock star left £140,000 out of pocket

26th August 2016

Proportionality rule makes mockery of justice, says rock star left £140,000 out of pocket

Queen guitarist Brian May says he has been left more than £140,000 out of pocket despite successfully suing a property developer over noise and disturbance.

Under new rules that limit the recovery of the costs in civil court actions to a “proportionate” amount, the musician’s initial £208,000 claim was reduced by a judge to just £35,000.

Dr May believes the so-called proportionality test is making it much harder for people to fight their corner for fear of being unable to claim their legal costs.

The former rock star and his wife had accepted £25,000 in settlement in a private nuisance case – but because their subsequent costs bill was so significantly reduced, the couple have been left with significant financial shortfall.

The action was brought after the owner of one of the houses on Dr May’s street began excavating a basement two stories deep.

Writing in The Times, Dr May said the work had gone on for three years, causing “immense distress”. He sued the developer of the property, Wavell Group Plc, and its owner, Farid Bizarri, for the loss of quality of life.

But he said that as a result of taking action, he has been left out of pocket to the tune of £141,000.

“Where’s the proportionality in that? Where’s the justice? This absurd proportionality rule makes it impossible for any wronged party to protect himself.

“This proportionality rule is a nonsense, and makes a mockery of justice; it is yet another way of ensuring that the super-rich can do anything that they like, including destroying the quality of life of those around them.

“What was in the mind of the people who introduced this ridiculous rule of proportionality?”

How can our Property Dispute Lawyers help?

Our expert team of lawyers will always aim to effect a speedy, sensible and pragmatic solution without the need to resort to court proceedings wherever possible, saving time and thereby limiting costs and stress.

Furthermore they will ensure your legal costs are always clear – with no surprises.

To find out how we can help you, call us on 01394 458007 or visit us at one of our offices in Ipswich, Felixstowe, Hadleigh, Woodbridge or Melton.

Practice Areas
Dispute Resolution
Importation & E-fulfilment Adviser
Chartered Legal Executive and Associate
Chartered Legal Executive, Associate
Chartered Legal Executive Associate
Blog Posts

Is your fulfilment business under threat?


The Fulfilment House Due Diligence Scheme - the new weapon in the war on…

Read More
Upcoming Events

FREE Seminar – Planning your future


Gotelee Solicitors invite you to a FREE seminar which will provide you with some…

Read More
News Posts

Victims of child sexual abuse could be refused compensation under new guidelines


Campaigners are urging the Government to rethink guidance that could see victims of child…

Read More


"Friendly and helpful staff. A smooth and efficient legal service."

- MR

"Professional yet friendly service available from a conveniently located office."

- JR

"Clear, helpful advice, polite and friendly, prompt attention."

- GP

"High degree of professionalism whilst remaining sympathetic and friendly."

- PC

"Helpful and swift service, delivered in a friendly and approachable way."

- AC

"Gotelee inspires a sense of calm, confidence, trust & history."

- PB

"Determination, patience and diligence of Chris Moffat."


"Diana really seemed to care and made the whole process as painless as possible."

- PL

"Rhonda Pryke was very helpful, explained what was to happen, dealt with queries very efficiently."

- DH

"All reception staff very friendly, Hilary Durrell made everything simple so I could understand what was needed."

- AD

Please select preferred method of contact

* We will only contact you by telephone if you select this as primary form of contact.