The long road to ill-health dismissal

7th January 2016

The long road to ill-health dismissal

Assorted pills

 

It’s a question that crops up frequently: for how long does an employee need to be off work before their employer can terminate their contract?

Concern for an employee’s welfare is one thing. But there are operational challenges around covering that person’s work, keeping their job open, and making changes to their role or working environment that could help them return. It’s rarely an easy situation to manage and it can be difficult to judge when the time has come to safely bring employment to an end. Of course this will vary from situation to situation.

One of the main points to come out of Monmouthshire County Council v Harris is that, when looking at a decision to dismiss a sick employee, a key question is: could the employer have reasonably been expected to wait any longer? (This is alongside the question of whether there was adequate consultation with the employee and whether the employer obtained and had proper regard to up-to-date medical advice.)

Relevant considerations in this context include:

  • Was it fair to dismiss, given any background failings by the employer?
  • Was it fair to dismiss, given the pressures faced by the employer at the time and going forward?
  • Could the employer have been expected to allow more time?
  • Was dismissal within the range of reasonable responses?

The EAT allowed the employer’s appeal; the tribunal had taken the wrong approach in finding in favour of Ms Harris.

How can our Employment Lawyers help you?

Our experienced team can offer you advice on all areas of employment law, whether you are a business or an individual. We have offices in Ipswich, Hadleigh and Felixstowe where our solicitors will be happy to arrange a meeting at a time that suits you. To arrange an initial meeting  please contact employment@gotelee.co.uk, 01473 211121 or contact one of our solicitors directly using the details on the side of the screen.

Monmouthshire Council v Harris

Blog Posts

The Woodbridge Regatta and Riverside Fair

15/06/2017

One of the most important events in the Woodbridge calendar – The Woodbridge Regatta…

Read More
Upcoming Events

Brass on the Grass – Ipswich Hospital Band 2017

04/05/2017

Gotelee Solicitors are delighted to be supporting The Ipswich Hospital Band with their band…

Read More
News Posts

Hotelier fails in bid to quash prison sentence for fire safety breaches

28/06/2017

Fire safety is at the top of the national agenda following the recent tragedy…

Read More

Testimonials

"Clarity and speed. A refreshing absence of legal jargon and gobblodygook!"

- PS

"The down to earth manner of the solicitors."

- GN

"Not too formal - felt like a chat with a friend."

- JG

"As your entire service was excellent, it is not possible to single out anything special to mention."

- AH

"A big firm with a local touch!"

- RG

"Great service, never made things complicated!"

- JW

"Warm friendly service with clear responses to all my questions."

- BF

"Mr Rowland was sincere, approachable, understanding and professional throughout."

- GD

"Personal, prompt, caring and communication by email was excellent."

- Anonymous

"Feeling at ease knowing that they were putting my best interests first."

- Anonymous

Please select preferred method of contact

* We will only contact you by telephone if you select this as primary form of contact.